In 1967 I was eleven years old and
a dyed-in-the-wool DC Comics kid. One of
the dozens of comics kicking around our house at the time was Action #350, with
this stupendous cover by Curt Swan.
Looking back on this cover now, I
notice that the writer of this cover’s blurb was playing a little fast and
loose with history, since according to knowledge of the time cave men were
around tens or hundreds of thousands of years ago, but not a megaannum (look it up) ago! The “lived and died a million years ago” is a
little bit of an exaggeration.
Now, compare the
anatomically-accurate-in-every-detail Curt Swan art on the cover to the
interior art by Wayne Boring.
Now, I know that Boring is considered a great
Superman artist -- I personally LOVE the way he portrays the lovely ladies of
DC -- but in my opinion Boring’s art is wa-a-a-y, t-o-o, cartoony. Compare Curt Swan’s depiction of the skull to
Boring’s:
It’s like comparing a third-grader’s art to da Vinci!
Anyway, I remember this comic specifically because of an
argument it sparked between me and my sister Sue, who would have been 17 at the
time.
It’s one of those nerdy arguments like the one in the movie
Stand
By Me about who would in in a fight -- Mighty Mouse or Superman?
Just judging by the cover art, Sue and I argued about
whether it was possible for this skeleton in the super-suit to actually BE
SUPERMAN’S SKELETON.
I said that (theoretically) it was entirely possible that
this COULD BE Superman’s bones.
On the
other hand, Sue said this could not be.
He couldn’t be there twice -- alive AND dead.
My response was that it could easily be him, both alive and
dead, sketching it out this way:
Suppose
that tomorrow Superman flies into the past.
Somehow he is killed in this cave, IN THE PAST.
Now, eons later, Perry White and Superman
stumble across these bones.
It would not
be violating the “time travel laws,” because this skeleton is the skeleton of TOMORROW’S
Superman.
This Superman, standing there
looking at the bones, tomorrow will fly into the past and die, so that today’s
Superman can find the body.
See? not a contradiction at all!
To which Sue responded, “It can’t happen like that?”
“Why not?” I demanded.
“Because!” she said.
This being my sweet sister Sue, this came out pronounced, “Be-cuzz --
Just be-cuzz!”
What do YOU think? Could
Superman be there -- both alive -- AND dead?
Until next time, don't forget to watch The Rat Patrol on ABC on Monday nights!
